November 20, 2026

“Home, I’m Darling” reviewed by Paul Lisnek

**** / 4 “Nostalgia Gets a Dream Home—and a Reality Check; A Must See at Timeline Theatre!”

There is a difference between making a beautiful home and building a happy life. In TimeLine Theatre’s excellent production of Home, I’m Darling, that difference becomes the foundation for a production that is funny, thought-provoking, surprising, and surprisingly unsettling. Featuring a terrific ensemble and a gorgeous set, this Chicago premiere makes an inviting case for stepping inside the past—and then realizing that things may not have been as glorious as you thought.

Written by Laura Wade and directed by Mechelle Moe, the play introduces Judy and Johnny, a couple pursuing an idealized version of 1950s domestic bliss. What at first appears to be a matter of decorating taste, it becomes an immersive commitment to an idealized vision of marriage, gender roles, and happiness that becomes increasingly difficult to sustain. Wade uses that premise to ask a compelling question: What happens when the life we design for ourselves begins to disguise the people we actually are?

Claire Kaplan is outstanding as Judy, the woman at the center of her meticulously curated world. Her performance gives the production an essential emotional anchor: however questionable Judy’s choices may be, the desire behind them encourages a consideration with a premise that seems worth taking seriously. Judy’s full and complete investment in her dream becomes the production’s most intriguing human puzzle and complication.

Elliot Sagay is equally impressive as Johnny. Together, Kaplan and Sagay give the marriage the dramatic weight it needs to have us buy in. Home, I’m Darling relies on our having an interest in the people inside that central relationship, not merely on recognizing the ideas they represent. These two performers make that distinction matter. Their interaction keeps the play grounded in the personal stakes of maintaining a shared fantasy.

As the family friend, Maya Rowe (Rose in Titanique) is terrific as Fran, adding another and consequential strong presence to an already engaging ensemble; she often steals the moment in a good way and countered by her husband Marcus, well played by Brandon Dahlquist who has a strong handle on everything we don’t want in a husband. Gloria Imseih Petrelli is likewise excellent as Johnny’s boss, Alex. She walks the line between a possible threat to the Judy-Johnny marriage while simultaneously being oblivious to the concept, at least at first. And as always, a special recognition must be given to one of my all-time favorite actors, Janet Ulrich Brooks who plays Jody’s mother Sylvia. A comedic force in her early scene, she ultimately teaches the lesson of the show in her final captivating scene, greeted with great applause at its conclusion. The 1950’s may not have been the 1950’s Judy has long fantasized that they were!

One cannot review this show without a compliment to the magnificent  set, which is a stunning pleasure in its own right. Beautiful, striking and immediately inviting, it gives the production a visual centerpiece worthy of every ounce of attention paid to it. This is a play in which the home must matter, and the set design makes that importance unmistakable and undeniable.  In fact, the setting “belongs” to the argument of the evening. Almost a character itself, the beautifully and intricately designed room expresses care, aspiration, and identity; it represents something its inhabitants feel obliged to live up to. It becomes a symbol of the increasingly strained domestic idealism; the set is far more than just beautiful scenery. In fact, its appeal helps to explain why Judy’s dream may be so difficult to surrender.

What makes Home, I’m Darling so satisfying is the tension between its appealing premise and its uncomfortable implications as they roll out. Nostalgia promises simplicity, but at what cost? The production invites us to consider how easily a chosen lifestyle can become a performance of happiness, a question that sits at the heart of Wade’s examination of marriage, identity, and a supposedly perfect past.

Do not miss Home, I’m Darling! In fact, you should come for the inviting home and the comedy; but you’ll leave thinking seriously about what it takes to live honestly inside the life you have chosen to make for yourself.

—————————–

Home, I’m Darling plays at TimeLine Theatre, 5035 N. Broadway, Chicago, Now extended through December 20, 2026, with performances as follows:

Tuesdays             7:30pm
Wednesdays       7:30pm
Thursdays           7:30pm ( except Turkey Day)
Fridays                7:30pm
Saturdays           2:00pm & 7:30pm
Sundays              2:00pm

Show Type: Comedy/Drama

Box Office: 773-281-8463

www.timelinetheatre.com

Timeline is located at5035 N. Broadway in Chicago

Running time is approximately two hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.

To see what others are saying, visit www.theatreinchicago.com, go to Review Round-Up and click at “Home, I’m Darling”.