December 24, 2024

The 51st Equity Jeff Awards

CHICAGO, IL – The 51st Annual Jeff Awards Ceremony took place on October 21, 2019, during a spirited evening at Drury Lane Oakbrook.  “Frankenstein,” produced by Remy Bumppo Theatre Company, took home five awards, including Best Production – Play in the Midsize category. Court Theatre also took home five awards, including the coveted Ensemble Award for “For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide/When the Rainbow is Enuf” and four awards for “Photograph 51.” Steppenwolf Theatre Company’s production of “Downstate” received the Jeff Award for Best Production – Play in the Large category. The award for Best Production – Musical in the Large category went to “Six” at Chicago Shakespeare Theater, and the award for Best Production – Musical in the Midsize category went to “Caroline, or Change,” produced by Firebrand Theatre in partnership with TimeLine Theatre Company.

Three new works received Jeff Awards this year. The award for New Work – Play was presented to Bruce Norris for “Downstate” at Steppenwolf Theatre Company, and  two awards for New Work – Musical were bestowed on David Cale for “We’re Only Alive for A Short Amount of Time” at Goodman Theatre in co-production with The Public Theater, and to Michael Mahler and Jason Brett for “Miracle,” produced by William A. Marovitz and Arny Granat.

In the acting categories, awards for Performer in Principal Role – Play went to Janet Ulrich Brooks (Maria Callas) for “Master Class” at TimeLine Theatre Company, and to Chaon Cross (Rosalind Franklin) for “Photograph 51” at Court Theatre.

E. Faye Butler (Rose) in “Gypsy” at Porchlight Music Theatre, and Barbara E. Robertson (Anna Edson Taylor) in “Queen of the Mist” at Firebrand Theatre received awards for Performer in a Principal Role – Musical. The Solo Performance award went to Joe Foust for “The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey” at American Blues Theater. The award for Performer in a Revue went to Robin DaSilva (Mahalia) in “Mahalia Jackson: Moving Thru the Light” at Black Ensemble Theater.

The awards for Performer in a Supporting Role – Play went to K. Todd Freeman (Dee) in “Downstate” at Steppenwolf Theatre Company, and to Brian Keys (Dwight Barnes) in “The Recommendation” at Windy City Playhouse. The awards for Performer in a Supporting Role – Musical went to Donica Lynn (Oda Mae) in “Ghost The Musical” at Theatre at the Center, and to Nat Zegree (Jerry Lee Lewis) in “Million Dollar Quartet” at Marriott Theatre.

A Special Jeff Award was presented to Teatro Vista. Over the last three decades, Teatro Vista has theatrically depicted the human experience from its unique Latinx perspective.  Founded in 1989 by actors Henry Godinez and Eddie Torres to provide a platform upon which stories born of and relevant to the Latino culture could be heard, Teatro Vista has enriched the Chicago theatre scene with haunting, humorous, historical and magical stories.  Teatro Vista, now under the artistic direction of Ricardo Gutierrez, continues to challenge and entertain Chicago audiences with its gifted ensemble of dynamic artists.

The evening was hosted by Steven Strafford with Music Direction by Charlotte Rivard-Hoster.  The ceremony was directed by Steve Scott and produced by Jeff Award member Deric Gochenauer.

The Jeff Awards has been honoring outstanding theatre artists annually since it was established in 1968. With up to 55 members representing a wide variety of backgrounds in theatre (including producers, directors, actors, playwrights, designers, professors of theatre, entertainment lawyers and agents, and theatre lovers), the Jeff Awards is committed to celebrating the vitality of Chicago area theatre by recognizing excellence through its recommendations, awards and honors.   Opening night judges include not only Jeff members but also the team of Artistic and Technical theatre volunteers (the “A/T Team”) which is comprised of artistic directors, producers, directors from major Chicago theatres, actors and designers. The Jeff Awards fosters the artistic growth of area theatres and theatre artists and promotes educational opportunities, audience appreciation and civic pride in the achievements of the theatre community. Each year, the Jeff Awards judges 300 theatrical productions and host two awards ceremonies. Originally chartered to recognize only Equity productions, the Jeff Awards established the Non-Equity Wing in 1973 to celebrate outstanding achievement in non-union theatre.

Here are all of the nominations and the winners. They are marked in bold italics

 

Production-Musical-Large (The Dr. Harlan Haimes Award)

Disney’s Beauty and the Best – Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (2019) – Drury Lane Productions
The Producers – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Next to Normal – Next to Normal (2019) – Writers Theatre
Six – Six (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
The Wizard of Oz – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre

Production – Play – Large

Downstate – Downstate (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Radio Golf – Radio Golf (2019) – Court Theatre
The Steadfast Tin Soldier – The Steadfast Tin Soldier (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Photograph 51 – Photograph 51 (2019) – Court Theatre
Indecent – Indecent (2019) – Victory Gardens Theater

Production Play – Midsize

Frankenstein – Frankenstein (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company
Noises Off – Noises Off (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
The Recommendation – The Recommendation (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
This Bitter Earth – This Bitter Earth (2019) – About Face Theatre
On Clover Road – On Clover Road (2019) – American Blues Theater
Something Clean – Something Clean (2019) – Rivendell Theatre Ensemble and Sideshow Theatre Company

Production-Musical-Midsize

A Chorus Line – A Chorus Line (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
A Gentleman’s Guide to Love & Murder – A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Caroline, or Change – Caroline, or Change (2019) – Firebrand Theatre i/a/w TimeLine Theatre Company
Gypsy – Gypsy (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre

Production – Revue

Women of Soul – Women of Soul (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater
Djembel! The Show – Djembe! The Show (2019) – Apollo Theater Chicago
You Can’t Fake the Funk: A Journey through Funk Music – You Can’t Fake the Funk (A Journey Through Funk Music) (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater

Ensemble – Musical or Revue

Million Dollar Quartet – Million Dollar Quartet (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Queen of the Mist – Queen of the Mist (2019) – Firebrand Theatre
You Can’t Fake the Funk: A Journey through Funk Music – You Can’t Fake the Funk (A Journey Through Funk Music) (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater
Six – Six (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater

Ensemble – Play

Twilight Bowl – Twilight Bowl (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Noises Off – Noises Off (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
Familiar – Familiar (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide / When the Rainbow is Enuf – For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow is Enuf (2019) – Court Theatre
Small Mouth Sounds – Small Mouth Sounds (2019) – A Red Orchid Theatre
Indecent – Indecent (2019) – Victory Gardens Theater

New Work – Musical (The Libby Adler Mages Award)

Michael Mahler and Jason Brett – Miracle (2019) – Miracle Productions Chicago LLC
David Cale and Matthew Dean Marsh – We’re Only Alive for A Short Amount of Time (2019) – Goodman Theatre i/a/w The Public Theater
Daniel Zaitchik – Darling Grenadine (2019) – Marriott Theatre

New Work – Play (The Libby Adler Mages Award)

Bruce Norris – Downstate (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Manual Cinema – Frankenstein (2019) – Court Theatre
Ike Holter – Lottery Day (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Jenny Connell Davis – The Scientific Method (2019) – Rivendell Theatre Ensemble
Mary Zimmerman – The Steadfast Tin Soldier (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
David Catlin – Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
David Auburn – The Adventures of Augie March (2019) – Court Theatre
Jen Silverman – Witch (2019) – Writers Theatre

Director – Play – Midsize

Ian Frank – Frankenstein (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company
Scott Weinstein – Noises Off (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
Jonathan Wilson – The Recommendation (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
Halena Kays – On Clover Road (2019) – American Blues Theater
Jess McLeod – Wolf Play (2019) – The Gift Theatre

Director – Play – Large – (The Michael Maggio Award)

Pam MacKinnon – Downstate (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Ron OJ Parson – Radio Golf (2019) – Court Theatre
Mary Zimmerman – The Steadfast Tin Soldier (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Ron OJ Parson – Too Heavy For Your Pocket (2019) – TimeLine Theatre Company (Wellington)
Vanessa Stalling – Photograph 51 (2019) – Court Theatre
Gary Griffin – Indecent (2019) – Victory Gardens Theater

Director – Musical – Midsize

Stephen Schellhardt – A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Lili Anne Brown – Caroline, or Change (2019) – Firebrand Theatre i/a/w TimeLine Theatre Company
Elizabeth Margolius – Queen of the Mist (2019) – Firebrand Theatre
Michael Weber – Gypsy (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Brenda Didier – A Chorus Line (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre

Director – Musical – Large

William Osetek – Mamma Mia! (2019) – Drury Lane Productions
Jim Corti – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Lucy Moss and Jamie Armitage – Six (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
David Cromer – Next to Normal (2019) – Writers Theatre
Amber Mak – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Alan Souza – Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (2019) – Drury Lane Productions

Performer in a Principal Role – Musical

Matt Crowle – A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Andres Enriquez – A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Rashada Dawan – Caroline, or Change (2019) – Firebrand Theatre i/a/w TimeLine Theatre Company
Jacqueline Jones – The Spitfire Grill (2019) – American Blues Theater
Barbara E. Robertson – Queen of the Mist (2019) – Firebrand Theatre
Blake Hammond – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Sean Fortunato – Roald Dahl’s Matilda the Musical (2019) – Drury Lane Productions
E. Faye Butler – Gypsy (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Jake Morrissy – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Kelly Felthous – Little Shop of Horrors (2019) – Drury Lane Productions

Performer in a Principal Role – Play

Namir Smallwood – True West (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Janet Ulrich Brooks – Master Class (2019) – TimeLine Theatre Company (Belmont)
Emily Berman – A Shayna Maidel (2019) – TimeLine Theatre Company (Wellington)
Bradley Armacost – The Woman in Black (2019) – PW Productions and Pemberley Productions
Meg Thalken – Four Places (2019) – The Den Theatre
Chaon Cross – Photograph 51 (2019) – Court Theatre
David Darlow – The Father (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company
Lawrence Grimm – Hannah and Martin (2019) – Shattered Globe Theatre
Wendy Robie – Elizabeth Rex (2019) – Oak Park Festival Theatre
Nicole Michelle Haskins – Hopelessly Devoted (2019) – Piven Theatre Workshop

Performer in a Supporting Role – Play

K. Todd Freeman – Downstate (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Janet Ulrich Brooks – Over the Tavern (2019) – Theatre at the Center
James Vincent Meredith – Radio Golf (2019) – Court Theatre
Brian Keys – The Recommendation (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
Alfred H. Wilson – Radio Golf (2019) – Court Theatre
Kirsten Fitzgerald – Sweat (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Sean Fortunato – Twelfth Night (2019) – Writers Theatre
Scott Parkinson – Twelfth Night (2019) – Writers Theatre
Patrick Agada – Something Clean (2019) – Rivendell Theatre Ensemble and Sideshow Theatre Company
Kelvin Roston, Jr. – Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom (2019) – Writers Theatre

Performer in a Supporting Role – Musical

Nat Zegree – Million Dollar Quartet (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Emily Goldberg – A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Dara Cameron – The Spitfire Grill (2019) – American Blues Theater
Jose Antonio Garcia – Gypsy (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Catherine Smitko – The Spitfire Grill (2019) – American Blues Theater
Marya Grandy – Irving Berlin’s Holiday Inn (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Alex Goodrich – Sweet Charity (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Kyrie Courter – Next to Normal (2019) – Writers Theatre
Sawyer Smith – Pippin (2019) – Mercury Theater Chicago
Donica Lynn – Ghost The Musical (2019) – Theatre at the Center

Performer in a Revue

Rhonda Preston – Style and Grace: A Tribute to Lena Horne and Nancy Wilson (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater
Aerial Williams – Style and Grace: A Tribute to Lena Horne and Nancy Wilson (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater
Robin DaSilva – Mahalia Jackson: Moving Thru the Light (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater
Rashad a Dawan – Djembe! The Show (2019) – Apollo Theater Chicago

Solo Performance

David Cale – We’re Only Alive for A Short Amount of Time (2019) – Goodman Theatre i/a/w The Public Theater
Ross Lehman – Sentimental Journey (2019) – Citadel Theatre Company
Matt Crowle – The Santaland Diaries (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Joe Foust – The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey (2019) – American Blues Theater
Alexis J. Roston – Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill (2019) – Congo Square Theatre Company

Scenic Design – Large

William Boles – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Kristen Robinson – Familiar (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company
Arnel Sancianco – Lottery Day (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Arnel Sancianco – Photograph 51 (2019) – Court Theatre
Todd Rosenthal – How to Catch Creation (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Kevin Depinet and Christopher Rhoton – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Todd Rosenthal – A Midsummer Night’s Dream (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater

Scenic Design – Midsize

Jeffrey D. Kmiec – Noises Off (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
Lauren Nigri – The Recommendation (2019) – Windy City Playhouse
Jeffrey D. Kmiec – Gypsy (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Joe Schermoly – This Bitter Earth (2019) – About Face Theatre
Angela Weber Miller – All Childish Things (2019) – First Folio Theatre
Arnel Sancianco – Something Clean (2019) – Rivendell Theatre Ensemble and Sideshow Theatre Company

Costume Design – Midsize

Jeff Hendry – A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Bill Morey – Gypsy (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Rachel Boylan – Pippin (2019) – Mercury Theater Chicago

Costume Design – Large

Ana Kuzmanic – The Steadfast Tin Soldier (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Jordan Ross – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Theresa Ham – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Rueben Echoles – You Can’t Fake the Funk (A Journey Through Funk Music) (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater
Ryan Park – Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (2019) – Drury Lane Productions
Hugh Durrant – Nell Gwynn (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater

Sound Design – Midsize

Jeffrey Levin – Small Mouth Sounds (2019) – A Red Orchid Theatre
Matt Reich – The Worst Mother in the World (2019) – Halcyon Theatre
Eric Backus – Wolf Play (2019) – The Gift Theatre
Eric Backus – The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey (2019) – American Blues Theater
Christopher Kriz – Frankenstein (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company

Sound Design – Large

Jeffrey Levin – A Shayna Maidel (2019) – TimeLine Theatre Company (Wellington)
Rick Sims – Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Adam Rosenthal – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Mikhail Fiksel – Cambodian Rock Band (2019) – Victory Gardens Theater
Kyle Vegterand Ben Kauffman – Frankenstein (2019) – Court Theatre
Ray Nardelli – Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom (2019) – Writers Theatre

Lighting Design – Large

William C. Kirkham – Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Greg Hofmann – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Tim Deiling – Six (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
Greg Hofmann and Jesse Klug – A Midsummer Night’s Dream (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
Ryan O’Gara – Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (2019) – Drury Lane Productions
Jesse Klug – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre

Lighting Design – Midsize

Alexander Ridgers – Pinocchio (2019) – The House Theatre of Chicago
Cat Wilson – Queen of the Mist (2019) – Firebrand Theatre
John Kelly – This Bitter Earth (2019) – About Face Theatre
Mike Durst – Frankenstein (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company
Denise Karczewski – A Chorus Line (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre

Choreography

Brenda Didier – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Denis Jones – Irving Berlin’s Holiday Inn (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Alex Sanchez – Sweet Charity (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Christopher Chase Carter – A Chorus Line (2019) – Porchlight Music Theatre
Brenda Didier – Pippin (2019) – Mercury Theater Chicago

Fight Choreography

Matt Hawkins – Hamlet (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
Matt Hawkins – Witch (2019) – Writers Theatre
Jon Beal – Cardboard Piano (2019) – TimeLine Theatre Company (Wellington)
Ned Mochel – True West (2019) – Steppenwolf Theatre Company

Music Direction

Andra Velis Simon – Caroline, or Change (2019) – Firebrand Theatre i/a/w TimeLine Theatre Company
Tom Vendafreddo – The Producers (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Malcolm Ruhl – The Spitfire Grill (2019) – American Blues Theater
Roberta Duchak and Joe Beighton – Six (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
Robert Reddrick – You Can’t Fake the Funk (A Journey Through Funk Music) (2019) – Black Ensemble Theater

Original Music in a Play

Kyle Vegter and Ben Kauffman – Frankenstein (2019) – Court Theatre
Andre Pluess and Amanda Dehnert – The Steadfast Tin Soldier (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Rick Sims – Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Richard Woodbury – The Winter’s Tale (2019) – Goodman Theatre
Christopher Kriz – Frankenstein (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company

Puppet Design

Phillip Huber – Darling Grenadine (2019) – Marriott Theatre
Liz Breit and Drew Dir – Frankenstein (2019) – Court Theatre
Chicago Puppet Studio – Pinocchio (2019) – The House Theatre of Chicago
Chicago Puppet Studio – The Steadfast Tin Soldier (2019) – Lookingglass Theatre Company
Stephanie Diaz – Wolf Play (2019) – The Gift Theatre

Artistic Specialization

Richard Jarvie – Nell Gwynn (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
Kristy Leigh Hall – Frankenstein (2019) – Remy Bumppo Theatre Company -makeup
Casey Schilio and Wendy A. Huber – All Childish Things (2019) – First Folio Theatre props

Projection Design

Rasean Davonte Johnson – Frankenstein (2019) – Court Theatre
Mike Tutaj – Hamlet (2019) – Chicago Shakespeare Theater
Anthony Churchill – The Scientific Method (2019) – Rivendell Theatre Ensemble
G. Max Maxin IV – The Absolute Brightness of Leonard Pelkey (2019) – American Blues Theater
Kevan Loney – The Wizard of Oz (2019) – Paramount Theatre
Editors notes
The evening was longer, or it seemed to be, than previous awards. Might I also say louder. Perhaps it was due to being so close to Halloween and Frankenstein winning so many Jeff Awards. Steven Strafford was an ideal host for the evening, mixing up his comic routines and silly costume changes and having a MAD-LIB reading of Shakespeare by Alex Goodrich. The musical numbers from the nominees were spread out fairly evenly, but the acceptance speeches were far too long!
It was a great year of diversity and nice to see some new faces take the stage ( and awards). Congratulations to all of the winners, and to those who were nominated. It is an honor to be in a city like Chicago where our theater community is as close to each other as it is. The theatre at Drury Lane was filled with emotion for several hours and the one that stood out is that of LOVE!